Campaign comments

[db0]

I was thinking, since we already have the statistics server collecting data for official and unofficial campaings, would it be possible to implement an option at the end of the scenario where the player could comment on the scenario. This could be put perhaps as an extra button only when the scenario is finished.

This could help get some player feedback without making them join the forum, look for the campaign thread and comment. It would also help connect the comment with the problematic scenario.

The campaign developer could then get a feed for his comments and see what people say about it.

[tsr]

You mean something like this?

I do like the idea, hope it gets some support.

/tsr

[MarkP]

I like this idea - I think it would improve the quality of the feedback too, as it is surely easier to comment on a scenario as soon as you finish it than having to wait until the next time you get to the forums (if you come here at all).

One addition I'd add would be the ability to attach a replay of the scenario.

Of course, I'd imagine this wouldn't be trivial to implement, but I would really like to see it. It could make a big difference to the amount of feedback user-made campaigns get.

[gotrek860]

I likie this idea, too very useful, and in case of defeat, the player could tell us why it's too difficult.

[db0]

You mean something like this?

I do like the idea, hope it gets some support.

/tsr

Not exactly, as this is more of a rating system for the whole campaign rather than the specific scenario. What I'd like initially is just the option to send a single comment to the stats page so that developer might get some feedback and the player finds it easy to provide it.

[Baufo]

I, as a campaign maintainer, would like this.