My second map, your opinion please!

[EmKaY57]

Hello guys,

I created my second Map and wanted to know, what u guys think of this.
I'd like to get constructive criticism.

Picture of the map:

Spoiler:

If someone wants the map, I'll upload it.

[Dunno]

It looks good, but it's unplayable. All 1v1v1 matches are uneven but on this map they would be just terrible. Player 1 is too far away, imo and has no village that can be captured by leader or infantry in the first turns.

[EmKaY57]

The windmill can be captured by leader in the first turn, and Player 1 is not too far away, its just a optical illusion ^^
From the middle of the 3 bases to the middle of the map, there are 19 fields.
All three paths and caves are exactly symmetrical.

[Dunno]

If you say so... now that you mention it, it does look symmetrical. And I also didn't realize the windmill is a village.
However, my point still stands that 1v1v1 matches are uneven from the very definition

[EmKaY57]

Yeah thats true

[Caphriel]

Typically, windmills are not villages, and modifying them to behave as villages is probably a bad design, because players will expect them to just be cosmetic.

[TheScribe]

Looks like a great map. Is it on the addons server? Because I want to download it.

And it did look unbalanced at first, but then I looked at the actual hexes and it's not. Great job of balancing.

[Colouredbox]

I'm not sure about all that sand, but I guess drakes would suffer from removing it.
Also caves have too much "cave" hexes in them.