Character Voices (Test with Orcs)
Moderator: Forum Moderators
Ideas:
Consider the following two games that used voices:
All versions of Warcraft/Starcraft have had voice recordings. Though quite tame in Warcraft I, they made them ridiculous in the later games. The only redeeming value of the voices in Warcraft is that they are funny. That's it. They'll occasionally have serious ones for main characters, but they are ruined by the triggering mechanism (every frikin time you click on them/every time you give them a command). The vocalization does not seem natural.
Compare this to Myth: The Fallen Lords, the best use of in-game voices I've ever seen, imo. Each unit had a quite terse selection of things they would say - not a long-winded "YOUR COMMAND, SIRE!", but rather a simple "sir?." And this would happen less than 1/5 of the time you selected them. Muted, simple, and more than anything else, realistic sounding.
Granted, I hope wesnoth does not go for selection-triggered acknowledgments.
Second, they had vocalizations for attacking, dying, successful kills, and friendly fire - warcraft only had attacking and dying, and only had the attacking one in version 3.
Friendly fire was actually quite funny in certain cases - the scottish flavoured Berserks would yell, though not always, "God damn your eyes!" Others would say "Watch it!"
Anyhow, I think a very important part of such an addition to the game would be the addition of different vocals for an attack and an attack where the attacker is unharmed. Perhaps a flawless kill sound - for the attacker who kills without being hurt:
Consider - an Orc Lord who says "Come to me - come and die!" after disposing of some elf archer or otherwise.
I think also that reserving bellicose vocals for those who deserve them - high level units - would make the flavor of the game better as well.
Consider the following two games that used voices:
All versions of Warcraft/Starcraft have had voice recordings. Though quite tame in Warcraft I, they made them ridiculous in the later games. The only redeeming value of the voices in Warcraft is that they are funny. That's it. They'll occasionally have serious ones for main characters, but they are ruined by the triggering mechanism (every frikin time you click on them/every time you give them a command). The vocalization does not seem natural.
Compare this to Myth: The Fallen Lords, the best use of in-game voices I've ever seen, imo. Each unit had a quite terse selection of things they would say - not a long-winded "YOUR COMMAND, SIRE!", but rather a simple "sir?." And this would happen less than 1/5 of the time you selected them. Muted, simple, and more than anything else, realistic sounding.
Granted, I hope wesnoth does not go for selection-triggered acknowledgments.
Second, they had vocalizations for attacking, dying, successful kills, and friendly fire - warcraft only had attacking and dying, and only had the attacking one in version 3.
Friendly fire was actually quite funny in certain cases - the scottish flavoured Berserks would yell, though not always, "God damn your eyes!" Others would say "Watch it!"
Anyhow, I think a very important part of such an addition to the game would be the addition of different vocals for an attack and an attack where the attacker is unharmed. Perhaps a flawless kill sound - for the attacker who kills without being hurt:
Consider - an Orc Lord who says "Come to me - come and die!" after disposing of some elf archer or otherwise.
I think also that reserving bellicose vocals for those who deserve them - high level units - would make the flavor of the game better as well.
Talk about resurrecting ancient topics. I'd forgotten I made these posts a year ago. This actually seems like a good idea in retrospect, but I suppose that we never got the voice support for it. Sound/music has always been Wesnoth's weakpoint. Anyone interested in doing voice recordings a year later?
Creator of Under the Burning Suns
Like the Sims?scottmac wrote:Another choice for voices (at least for the non-human characters) might be to use a
made-up language. For example, something like Tolkien's languages. Then the voices wouldn't
need to be translated.
Hope springs eternal.
Wesnoth acronym guide.
Wesnoth acronym guide.
I was just in the studio with a friend and did some voiceover for the swedish translation. We did the intro to Heir to the throne and rise of wesnoth. Right now everything is in one _large_ wav but I will try to cut it and post encoded sentencies.
So now the race is on, which language will be first to have complete voiceover
So now the race is on, which language will be first to have complete voiceover