Direction of sun movement
Moderator: Forum Moderators
Direction of sun movement
Do not make your decision based on how easy the change would be, OK? Assume that right now we do not have either image, and we are deciding which to make when we do make it.
So... which would, for YOU, be more intuitive - the sun moves from left to right, which is supposed to look as if you are in a northerly latitude looking south, or the sun moves from right to left, which is supposed to look like you are in a northerly latitude looking north?
(here's a crudely drawn comparison to show what i mean)
So... which would, for YOU, be more intuitive - the sun moves from left to right, which is supposed to look as if you are in a northerly latitude looking south, or the sun moves from right to left, which is supposed to look like you are in a northerly latitude looking north?
(here's a crudely drawn comparison to show what i mean)
For I am Turin Turambar - Master of Doom, by doom mastered. On permanent Wesbreak. Will not respond to private messages. Sorry!
And I hate stupid people.
The World of Orbivm
And I hate stupid people.
The World of Orbivm
-
- Moderator Emeritus
- Posts: 2232
- Joined: March 26th, 2004, 10:58 pm
- Location: New York, New York
This is really weird. The poll seems to reveal a near-perfectly-even split of opinion. The fact that people's intuitions can be so evenly divided into two opposing cases...
OK, fine, maybe I only find it fascinating because I'm a psych major.
OK, fine, maybe I only find it fascinating because I'm a psych major.
"Pure logic is the ruin of the spirit." - Antoine de Saint-Exupéry
Maybe it suggests that there's a near-perfect split between the two types of gamers: those who have ever been outdoors, and those who shun "the big room," and think of the sun as something that moves across an abstract map, not a real object in the sky.Sangel wrote:This is really weird. The poll seems to reveal a near-perfectly-even split of opinion.
If you trace the arc of the sun (or moon or planets) with your arm, you will inevitably trace from left to right, because if you tried to trace from right to left, your arm would have to go behind your body, and arms don't bend that way (at least not easily). Or you'd have to bend over backwards so far that you'd probably end up falling on your keister. Either way, the notion of the sun moving from right to left is associated with pain.
But if all you've ever seen of the world outside your (parent's) basement is on maps, then I suppose it might make sense to think of the sun as moving from right to left. But, oh, what a sad, sad existence.
Ok, ok, I'll quit teasing now. But I'll leave you with this final thought. The ancient Chinese drew their maps with south being up. Wouldn't this whole issue be much simpler if we were all ancient Chinese? Um, ancient Chinese with Pentium-powered PCs, of course.
Or that there are more of us southern hemisphere types around than you think... See the player locations map on the Wiki (and add yourself to the map).xtifr wrote:Maybe it suggests that there's a near-perfect split between the two types of gamers: those who have ever been outdoors, and those who shun "the big room," and think of the sun as something that moves across an abstract map, not a real object in the sky.
I am from northern hemisphere and voted right-to-left because IMO its playing better with maps of Wesnoth east on the right, west on the left. Sun moving in opposite direction is intuitive only when thinking about these things apart. Seeing them besides each other and contradicting would be strange.
I grew up in a house that faced south, so I'm used to the sun rising on my left and setting on my right. However, I would suggest that you not change the pictures. It took me about two scenarios to get used to the pictures as they are now (i.e., the length of the tutorial). I don't want to have to un-learn that.
Since the votes are so evenly split, maybe this would make a good option to set in Preferences.
Kristo
Since the votes are so evenly split, maybe this would make a good option to set in Preferences.
Kristo
This is what i've been saying; make it a preference!Kristo wrote:I grew up in a house that faced south, so I'm used to the sun rising on my left and setting on my right. However, I would suggest that you not change the pictures. It took me about two scenarios to get used to the pictures as they are now (i.e., the length of the tutorial). I don't want to have to un-learn that.
Since the votes are so evenly split, maybe this would make a good option to set in Preferences.
Kristo
For I am Turin Turambar - Master of Doom, by doom mastered. On permanent Wesbreak. Will not respond to private messages. Sorry!
And I hate stupid people.
The World of Orbivm
And I hate stupid people.
The World of Orbivm
- Simons Mith
- Posts: 821
- Joined: January 27th, 2005, 10:46 pm
- Location: Twickenham
- Contact:
Re: Direction of sun movement
Umm... looking north from a northerly lattitude you won't see the sun at all . Does that answer the question? Also, movement from left to right is clockwise, and analogous clocks even in this digital age are a world-wide symbol of time passing.turin wrote:So... which would, for YOU, be more intuitive - the sun moves from left to right, which is supposed to look as if you are in a northerly latitude looking south, or the sun moves from right to left, which is supposed to look like you are in a northerly latitude looking north?
Try some Multiplayer Scenarios / Campaigns