The Battle for Wesnoth Forums

Don't you think that it is actually huge problem that Battle for Wesnoth is only balanced for medium sized maps, where you play 1v1 for 3 hours long (I still don't believe undeads are any good on such maps though) and that balance on much more popular smaller maps - Isar Cross - is totally devasted?...

1 HI, 3 Spearmans, 1 Fencer/Cavalry - recruit units in this proportion. Cavalry works great versus augurs, while HI and Fencers do well versus skirmishers. Avoid other units.

Will there be update of bots for Wesnoth 1.16?

1v1 radarsu (drakes) vs Talos (elves) on Fallenstar Lake.

Radarsu win. No replay, we both closed game too fast.

I agree with all the changes except for adding hardy trait. Maybe it gives dwarves some advantage in orc matchup, but it gives undead even harder kick in a butt in dwarves vs undead matchup, which is already unfavorable. I find it unnecessary complication. Just remove healthy trait instead - simple ...

General: ... Orcs > Undead ... Im not sure I've ever heard anyone claming Orcs > Undead. I know for a while there people thought Undead was far superior in the Orc matchup. Is there a reason you think this matchup is imbalanced? Troll is 13g cost. Very hard to deal with for undeads. 2 adepts often ...

General:
Loyalists > Drakes

Dwarves > Elves
Orcs > Elves

Dwarves > Undead
Elves > Undead
Orcs > Undead

Medium & big maps:
Drakes > Dwarves

Small maps (Isar's Cross size):
Orcs > Drakes
Undead > Drakes

I haven't followed a topic for a while, I came back to it and read through all the posts. 1. Nerfing orc archer: Some people suggested nerfing orc archer damage. That's a big NO. He is good, maybe even too good, but only thing that can be nerfed is his exp, hp or melee damage. Any other changes woul...

This game was created for free. People work on it for free. No-one here is getting paid for what they do. When I and some other people wanted better Dunefolk we started to work on it and we are trying to make them as good as we possibly can. Not to mention developers who work on this game for years...

The only reason I responded to this thread in the first place is because I dont want anyone to actually believe the things you said make sense. That's exactly what I felt. So your purpose wasn't either help or suggesting other balance changes. At least somehow a miracle happened and I forced you to...

So if I don’t think some unit should be changed then that means I don’t know how it should be changed and why its not balanced? Funny. I said I won’t talk about all the balance changes here, nothing would come of it, please accept that instead of continuing to trying to provoke me. What I mean - if...

Stats I have copied that are not actual, well then, you must mean some of the stats you used, like dwarvish fighter having 60% mountain defense. You're an awful human being. I meant hills and it's absolutely not hard for anyone to guess and understand what I meant. And that wasn't important informa...

@Krogen You should play some 1v1 on proper 1v1 maps before trying to balance the game. Besides, this is my ladder account: http://wesnoth.gamingladder.info/profil ... ame=Krogen But from what I read in your post you seem to be an exclusively isar player (correct me if im wrong), so you probably don...

@Pentarctagon Slightly tweaking the stats of multiple units in every Default faction however, is simply too wide-ranging and unfocused to have a very likely chance of being accepted. It's not wide-ranging and unfocused. Focus is one to make win-rates of all factions averaging 42-54% => 48-53%. I've...

I think we need some incontrovertible evidence of these unbalances, to address the sensations that regularly reemerge in the forums only to be shut down by the "guardians" of the balance. I think we need an automated tool which checks deeply online matches: what factions win more, which u...