The Battle for Wesnoth Forums

Those numbers are incorrect. For some reason you've added damage from the fencer's weakness to impact without taking into account the chance to hit (ie. even if the fencer had 100% defence and couldn't be hit at all, you'd be claiming it would take .2*22 damage). You also appear to be assuming that...

HI wins the guarding village battle hands down due to resistance imho, since most of the units effective at booting a HI is effective against fencer too. For the 1v1, i can give some real numbers: Defense = +30% for fencer Resistance = +50% for HI, -20% for fencer Non trait damage output, HI = 22, f...

Suggestion: if somone following the thread posts the replays together on the first thread page, it would be great.

I am available as a substitute on GMT.

Thief: IF I get very lucky and catch a Wose at night with some thiefs, then yes, they are cost effective. But this is not something to really rely on. I dont really understand why you cannot "catch" woses with thieves, who have 2 more base mp. Back stab at dusk,dawn or night absolutely sl...

I absolutely agree with Valensk wrt knalgan mirror. I would like to suggest a different fix for this problem, make the mountain defense 55% from 60%. This way there is no difference against mage using factions and only slightly weaker against drakes.

Dixie wrote:Huh... I wouldn't have thought that, personally. Isn't 6-4 strong enough for you on a lv1, especially ranged?

we are talking about archer advancements

Also I' not sure why you consider automatically that archer will transform in marksman Where is this? Here 2.Elvish archer: Powerful ranged attack. A ranger gets only a 2 damage increase while marksman gets 4 with 60% accuracy. Whether you meant it or not, people reading this post with get the noti...

what is the point of hiding while choosing random?

And your point being?

Rule number 13 "If both players agree that a situation that isn't covered by the rules arises they can, if they agree on the solution, decide themself how it should be handled."

Apart from this there are no rules governing starting TOD or shroud.(I assume it is up to players)

whats the point in you not looking at the leavers units when he/she will see your units when watching the replay. The fair solution would obviously be having the auto save ON and whoever leaves hosting the game from their save.

I second jb

How is venting your anger here going to solve anything?? The fact of the matter is that devs cannot do anything based on your current evidence.

I guess it is going to be hard for the devs to do something based on your evidence.

Gameplay could be speeded up. Unit management could be simplified. Any number of game circumstances could make a player desire to speed up gameplay or simplify unit management. So in the end you came up with 2 reasons. As far as unit management is concerned it is just point and click, majority of t...